Choice Of Forum Matters: Tax Court And District Court Reach Different Conclusions On Same Facts Regarding Penalties

By Bryan C. Skarlatos & Henry Stow Lovejoy
Journal of Tax Practice & Procedure
October - November 2017 Edition

Taxpayers in a dispute with the IRS have a choice of forum in which to litigate. The Tax Court provides a pre-payment judicial review while taxpayers who pay in advance can sue for refund in Federal District Court. The choice of forum can have a material impact on the outcome of the litigation as is demonstrated by the Federal District Court decision in McNeill1 (“McNeill 1”) and the Tax Court decision in McNeill2 (“McNeill 2”).

Full Article